The process of urban regeneration is hinged on adequate physical
planning. The conceptual basis of a people's ideology and civilization
in relation to how they choose to live will determine the success
of planned regeneration of their urban centres.
For many Nigerians, Fire protection is simply a passive aspect
of daily activities, yet it is evident that billions of Naira
is lost annually to fire.
However, the technicalities of fire protection of the environment
are far fetched from the common man on the street. In the event
of fire in our environment, all kinds of solutions and initiatives
are usually proffered by all who mean well at combating the fire
outbreak. This may logically account for the few successes we
have recorded at combating fire outbreaks. Unfortunately, this
reaction is a clear evidence of our none-structured approach and
it goes a long way to show how handicapped we are on this front
of national progress.
Till date, the country has no fire code in place. Although a
draft bill is in circulation, and it is in the process of review.
The struCture again is a source of concern. It must be stressed
that to effectively combat fire outbreaks of all forms and types,
it requires multidisciplinary inputs. This can only be done effectively
through rational, empirical, and equitable platforms of expertise
and disciplines.
There is a need to appraise by research aspects of, the built
environment in terms of standards and specifications, behavioral
patterns, rehabilitation, rescue and effective ways of combating
fire outbreaks. In this regard, it must be emphasized that no
one agency is adequate enough in it's self to handle all aspects.
The demand is for a structured approach that would enable inputs
at various levels, with the intent of having a harmonious direction
towards effectively combating incidences of fire. The protective
measure would be considered as standards. When these standards
are adhered to, they would be considered as preventive in the
first order of response to incidences of fire.
The Nigerian institute of Architects in 1985 put together a committee
that generated a fire code for Nigeria. Aspects of prevention
of occurrence of fire in buildings, prevention of fire spread,
escape for users of the building and capability to contain the
fire were discussed extensively. This foundational input by Architects
has been added to by the recent Fire (precaution and control)
Bill. This is a clear indication of efforts been made to better
the situation. However, the pressure on society to develop at
a frenzied pace has not helped the context of the environment
as well. The rate of physical development surely out-runs the
rate of monitoring and controls; yet the necessary checks are
simply non-existent or ignored.
In this paper, it would be imperative to view fire protection
from a holistic perspective. This will involve appraising issues
of community, building design, specifications and monitoring concepts,
as well as fresh insights into the bulk of these theories and
solutions.
2.0 COMMUNITY
2.1 Background: The context of community in urban regeneration
which is relevant to fire protection is clearly that of "social
response". The "image" of social response is so
bad in the minds of professionals and politicians alike. Aradeon
(1978) recalls "the military governor of Lagos State who,
on arrival from an Australian visit, announced that his government
was going to clear the slums of traditional Lagos and rebuild
it with modem apartments and shopping centres". (Gilbert
1982) simply puts it: "such views are both inconsistent and
superficial and lead to inappropriate policy responses. However,
we have not seen an end of these superficial eccentricisms in
our society. Since every event of fire remains a platform for
political rhetoric on efforts of government and the technical
core towards ensuring that the situation does not repeat itself.
2.2 The nature of fire protection: In every communal fabric this
must be relatively structured. The idea that a fire station should
be situated in each local government headquarters of the federation
should not be simply based on whimsical deduction from the past
or present situations. Rather, it should be based on adequate
evaluation of communal needs as they grow on a yearly or bi-yearly
basis. Since the ultimate purpose of fire protection is to save
life and property in the event of fire outbreak. The risk of bigger
fires and the incidences of fires are usually higher with increased
activities, population, as well as better technology ironically.
The fires that have ravished most of our markets are in most cases
attributed to electrical surges and sparks this been a new technology.
There is need to equip each community relative to its inherent
situations under its communal context. By so, adequately preventing
fire outbreaks, and in an event, be fully equipped to avert or
combat the situation before it becomes catastrophic. It would
not be out of place to accentuate this idea by locating adequate
fire fighting response team and equipments at every five kilometers
of pipe-line running through the length and breath of various
communities around the country. It is evident that hundreds of
lives have been lost due to pipe-line vandalism and explosions.
Nevertheless, there is need to capture the essence of responsiveness
by the required agencies. It is evident we can spend billions
of Naira in high technology monitoring system against vandalism.
How about spending half that amount to sustain protective measures
and ensuring standards? What is the price of the "Nigerian
life"? The challenge is to call on the private and public
sector to urgently do something about the "life" of
a Nigerian from such gruesome death in the event of fire outbreak.
Fire protection of the built and the unbuilt environment is essential
to human existence.
2.3 Physical Planning: It is common place to think that the way
to protect against fire is simply based upon adequate fire fighting
equipments. In order to avoid fighting fires, certain aspects
of the environment must be carefully planned and designed within
specific lines of thought that would simply cater for the avoidance
of incidences of fire. However, in the event of fire, aspects
of the environment that have been thoughtfully designed will ensure
adequate escape for the inhabitants, suppression of the fire,
reduction in the spread of the fife and consequently put out the
fire, thus reducing loss of life and property. Some months ago,
Tejuosho Market was on fire. When the President of the Nigerian
Institute of Architects visited the site, with the NIA built environment
committee, one of the prime complaints of fire fighters and shop
owners was their inability to access the origins of the fife.
This was attributed to poor walkways, no drive ways, cluttered
spaces and general inaccessibility within the market. Although,
the market was properly designed, and all aspects of safety observed.
Over the years, the need for growth, expansion, controls, and
monitoring were neglected. Parking spaces have been turned into
shops as well. As if this is not enough, even the main street
(Tejuosho Road) is an extension of the market itself. This again
is another evidence of social irresponsiveness which is clearly
hinged on physical planning.
At this juncture, it must be stressed that physical planning
and urban design are not simply about approval of development
plans or preparation of fictitious and academic environmental
impact analysis reports. It is about designing in response to
change. These changes occur daily as man tries to respond to his
environment by controlling the limiting factors he finds therein.
This can be achieved by the use of design as a tool to improve
prevailing conditions.
In order to keep these varying changes in perspective design must
always respond to the circumstantial. The essence of environmental
design in this regard is to ensure that the bits and pieces of
all environmental solutions proffered by professionals and expertise
are carefully articulated and neatly fitted into a holistic sustainable
environment. Fire protection is one of the major aspects for consideration.
2.4 The nature of physical developments: Various types of buildings
associated with physical development and the events of fire were
matched, the result shows that majority of fire incidences where
associated with market fires. (This was based on a comparative
study of records of fire incidences by the Federal fire service
and building type classifications by the Nigerian Institute of
Architects.) Physical developments are usually no events that
can be described as a happenstance. There is a likely evolution
of the built form in what ever context. This time frame involved
in its emergence is usually neglected until the situation becomes
catastrophic. Seldom will the designer be called upon; rather
any form of rescue is usually a matter of last resort. This scenario
has aided poor contextual appraisals of our environment and infused
in us a layback attitude bearing in mind that the consequences
may not confront us soon. As we would all agree when the consequences
ensue they are devastating. Fire in this instance would be out
of control. Since the preventive measures that should control
it are not in place and they cannot be installed in split seconds
of required response time.
2.5 Common occurrence of abuse: While driving along the Falomo
Bridge recently, someone pointed my attention to the police barracks
to see a 2 kva generator placed on the window sill of one of the
apartments. The oil and fuel was evidently dripping from the third
floor window sill into the lower floor window, with its visible
wet outline. To my surprise it was generating power. This was
an accident ready to happen. Although it may take a while before
it happens, this time lag is generally responsible for the abuse
and ineptitude shown by us.
It is one thing to design, it is another to monitor. Unfortunately,
the monitoring aspect is open ended. A query on monitoring is
usually left without prosecution or remedies. Even where there
are likely threats, it cannot be backed by law.
As we discuss this subject today, there is still no housing Act
or building Act in place in Nigeria, It is taking us over forty
years to develop this document, like many other things in our
society. These rudimentary documents are the first direct steps
to fire protection of life and property, Unfortunately, there
is no such thing as common place knowledge of what is acceptable
or not acceptable. Especially when dealing with people in an emergent
democracy and technology without previous knowledge of these experiences.
In a case where the fire bill is passed, without the building
and housing act in force, the physical developments project and
certification will become another tax system against developers
of the environment.
3.0 DESIGN CONCEPTS
The architect recognizes the environment as a system, the community
as a sub- system, the building as another sub- system within the
communal sub-system. All these systems are in a form of integration.
However, in his design, against loss by fire, he fragments his
building sub-system into components. The architect prioritizes
his components by placing them in hierarchy. By so dong he can
establish the basis for structural stability, functional spaces,
resistances to the elements and event of fire, as well as escapes.
These components enable him to allow various research inputs into
the aspects of improvements he would require in the building systems.
By reason of the assemblage style of the architect's components,
he can fragment his building so that fire in one area of the component
does not easily spread to other components. The same principle
can be applied at the community level between buildings instead
of massing a communal block; it is safer to fragment building
units within the mass.
Therefore, the building as a type gives us insight into the principle
behind the architects design tools which he utilizes in preventing
fire outbreaks as a matter of failure of buildings, or curtailing
the spread of fire from one component to another; as a matter
of individual units or a mass.
The fire protection tree gives us a clear indication of fire
protection in buildings and the various points where design plays
crucial roles.
4.0 SPECIFICATION CONCEPTS
The prevention of fire and protection of the environment and
assets go hand in hand. When fire is prevented, in the event of
its possible outbreak, design standard, specifications where upheld
would go a long way to protect the environment, life and property
from catastrophe.
Under intense heat, glass, shelters, plastics melt, wood bum,
the list is unending. However, the fire resistance rating of these
materials when used as components to form parts to a whole in
a building becomes very important. This could determine to a large
extent the survival of people and possibly reduce the loss and
damages that would ensue.
Specification concepts for fire protection can be grouped under
the following headings:
- Spatial context adequacy. - Escape adequacy
- Material resistance rating
- Component adequacy.
4.1 Spatial Context Adequacy:_Not all spaces in terms of volume
are adequate to negate the impact of fire at its various phases
from ignition. Some volumes for practical purposes of functional
use of that space are adequately designed to inhibit the spread
of fire. For instance, the use of an atrium within a space could
pose danger to people on the upper floors. The escape from multistory
complexes with atriums should always be away from the atrium.
Similarly, the allowable floor to ceiling height of various functional
spaces and the use of smoke vents can reduce the risk of fire
spread. Adequacy in this context must be strictly adhered to public
spaces and offices.
4.2 Escape Adequacy: The appropriate use of fIfe stairs, escape
stairs, appropriate door swings, escape tunnels and smoke vents,
are simple design basics that must not be ignored. In the event
of fire, it could be the dividing line between life and death.
More so, aspects of accessibility to the fire spots by rescue
operators, fire windows, door, halls, tunnels, layout plans, etc.
These must be clearly seen and easily accessed for quick rescue.
The principle of means of escape is the facility to reach a protected
"protected point" i.e. one protected from smoke and
fire within a given time (Nadine1982)
The use of primary means of escape, secondary means of escape
and possibly any alternative means of escape should be the goal
of good design. Considerations of width of the routes, restriction
of distance and traveling time to escape protected points. Smoke
control along escape routes is a very crucial technicality in
the design of buildings and other aspects of the built environment.
Control of fire by the use intumescent materials on adjacent walls
of escape routes can also alleviate the impact of intense heat
as well as the use of sprinkler systems.
4.3 Material Resistance Rating: firer resistance rating tables
and charts are available for materials in the construction industry.
Usually, these ratings are matched with the classification of
fire. Since materials are not built to resist all types of fires.
This would not be economical. However these materials are also
tested relative to time required to burn, disintegrate and loose
structural properties as well.
4.4 Classification of Fire:
Class' A" fire - free-burning materials (mud, cloth, paper)
Class 'B' fire - inflammable liquids (petrol, paraffin, kerosene)
Class 'c' fire - inflammable gases
Class 'D' fire metals (aluminum, calcium, plutonium)
*classification-NIAfire code 1985
4.5 Component Adequacy: Once materials resistance rating is adequate,
the next vital aspect of protection against fire is the component
itself. Since the building is a composition of components. Fragmentation
helps for adequacy against fire spread. However, fragmentation
has an impact on the rigidity and stability of the component.
Hence adequacy standards must be ascertained. This would ease
escape; retain rigidity and stability while retaining its inherent
fire resistance rating.
5.0 MONITORING CONCEPTS
The current quagmire we find ourselves calls for a national intervention,
and a rapid response to issues pertaining to fire protection.
Firstly, the law that empowers the codes must exist. Secondly,
the agencies instrumental in conceptualizing, monitoring and enforcing
must simultaneously be in place. Thirdly, in order not to throw
everyone behind bars, there must be social based interventions
that would seek to redirect popular opinion and notions from staid
responses towards the importance of these codes and the healthy
need for compliance. Various events of bush burning, private waste
burning, generators on balconies of apartment buildings, smoking
vehicles, to various acts of arson are basic responses that we
have in our environment. Some have led to tragic loss of lives.
The concept of monitoring must be such that fire protection is
not seen as an exclusive preserve of an agency; rather a collective
enculturation of the people. How they live. Hence, the enculturation
process must be a part of educational curricular for schools,
drills, for the working class, and non-working class.
5.1 Performance based regulatory system
As we beginning the process of standardization, passing of bills
and regulating the built environment it will be important to draw
our attention to global directions. The intent is to inform our
discretion so as to ensure that appropriate environment for cross
fertilization of concepts and ideas is created.
It is often the case to see that standards setting ends up as
academic non- adaptable document especially in the construction
sector of Nigeria. Since the impact does not suddenly reflect
on economics and politics. Performance based regulatory systems
simply focuses on out comes rather than specific solution. While,
Standards settings focuses on specifics of the regulatory intent
per item or process.
5.3 The nature of standards; These comprises of mandatory or
advisory objectives. hey can be categorized it four parts;
-test or measurement standards -procedural standards
- interoperability standards
-standard of professional practice
Where standards are unavailable or inappropriate such as for
the acceptance of innovative materials or methods, there exist
systems for technical approvals to give guidance on meeting functional
requirement.(Bukowski,2003)It is interesting to note that in Britain,
this is achieved by the British board of agreements in the United
States of America, by the evaluating services organization in
conjunction with model code development bodies. With the rate
of influx of various materials into Nigeria as well as speed of
development projects, it will be important to put in place an
inter agency organization that is empowered.
Similarly, the incorporation of due diligence aspects of regulatory
developments will go a long way to improve our lot on standards
and regulations that will form the body of monitoring initiatives.
5.2 Building regulatory systems: These consist of regulations
adopted into law by whatever legislative or administrative means.
Current legislative initiatives should seek not only to protect
life and property form fire disasters, but insist on performance
evaluation of the buildings and its environment. Performance evaluation
herein implies certification of levels compliance to building
regulations s well as fire standards. The only way these regulation
can be in effect is by a continuous appraisal until we develop
and evolve into such levels of environmental sensitivity.
6.0 CONCLUSION
Although it is evident that fire protection of the environment
and asset is extensive and science based. The need for the "Social
responsiveness" to its challenges is enormous.
The vacuum created by the lack of fire code for the nation has
been very devastating. More so, the rational behind the concepts
of protection of physical developments in the environment.
It has been suggested by the Nigerian Institute of Architects
working committee on the fire code (1985) that workshops and debates
would enhance future development of the fire code. Recently the
Nigerian investment promotion council held a national workshop
on market fire (July 29th, 2004) at the MUSON Centre in Lagos.
The issues of fire protection is gradually been seen as a national
problem that must be addressed. The need for a more pragmatic
stem toward combating fire, setting the stage for adequate fire
protection and engendering refoffils in this sector has been stressed.
In this paper, we have shown that, apart from fire fighting equipment,
and institutional frame work, there is a great need to understand
the process of the "built state" of our environment
by way of the various concepts associated with fire protection.
This been a guiding rule for protecting the built and unbuilt
environment against incidence of fire outbreak adequately.
7.0 Recommendations:
- All primary, secondary and tertiary schools must be integrated
into formal training on fire fighting basics and emergency/first
aid.
- All high rise offices, major complexes, markets, hospitals etc.
must undergo
routine fire drills performance certification for the physical
development and routine fire drills for personnel.
- Enforcement of the fire code must be done adequately.
- Pipeline must be equipped with fire detectors and fire fighting
response within 5 minutes of occurrence across the length and
breath of the communities where it truncates.
- Fire approval must be obtained for physical development projects.
- More research into fire ratings tests, assessment, and validation
of standards and procedures in line with technological progress.
- Location of fire stations in every community and equipped based
on possible/likely need.
- More work by fire services (police) to ensure that cases of
fire are known and documented with valid, and publishable proofs
for addition to knowledge.
References
1. Ogbogoh F.l (2004) "Market fire" a paper presented
at the seminar on Market fifes (July 29th, 2004) held at MUSON
Centre, Lagos.
2. Aradeon. D. (1978) " Regional assessment of Human settlements
policies in Nigeria Paper presented at the symposium on National
Human Settlements policies and theory held at the University of
Sussex. February, 1978.
3. Gugler, J. (1982) "The logic of Governmental Response",
Cities, poverty and development (Oxford University Press) New
York (p.I09).
4. The Nigerian Institutes of Architects: fire code for Nigeria,
fire code committee (1985) Sobowale,etal.
5. Odeleye A. (1983) Fire protection in buildings: ed. Omokhodion
N. A. (Nigeria Institute of Architects).
6. Nadine B.,(1982) Design for shopping centres, University Press,
Cambridge.
7. Bukowski.R.W,et al,(2001)Performance-based regulatory framework,
CIB world congress, Wellington NZ.
8. Bukowski.R.W,et al,(2003)Rule of standards in a performance-based
building regulatory system, CIB-CTBUH conference on tall buildings,
Kwalar Lumpur, Malaysia.
|